True to previous form, I've been listening to a podcast called The Conspiracy Guys.
Believe it or not, it's not some wide-eyed venture which believes everything it reads or sees. What you have instead are (often) five hour deep dives exploring a topic from both skeptical and traditional angles. At the end of each show, they have an "off the fence" moment where they discuss if the theories under discussion have any merit.
Very decent production values; the hosts are all Irish and have their banter down. One of the presenters is a stand-up comic. The only gripe I have is the usually front-loaded self-promotion and advertising, which I've gotten very adept at skipping past.