Terrible events in Paris. I’ve not been impressed with the hysteria. I’ve had to tell one Facebook friend that actually, her kids have been born in one of the wealthiest countries in the world during one of the best periods of history (even if we happen to be going through some bad times at the moment), after she made comments about not wanting to raise her kids in this world. I unfriended an uncle, largely on account of him informing any “fucking Muslim lovers” that they were not part of his family. I’ve called him out on his racist shit before. He means me and my brother.
Perspective is all important, and it is very difficult to do that from a position of hysteria. I have no wish to play whattaboutery with human lives, but we routinely go through periods where more people are killed in bombings in a single night in one of the Middle Eastern countries we’ve democratised, and that happens several nights of the week. Everyone should go out with an expectation that if they leave their home, they can conduct their business safely, whether that is in Paris, Baghdad or Damascus. The fact that we cannot is an ongoing collective human failure.
I am sure that most would agree that anyone that would target human life so indiscriminately deserves condemnation and that the families of the victims deserve a robust investigation into not just the perpetrators, but the network, the funding mechanisms and the underlying causes. I despair at some of the stuff I’ve seen from the Born Yesterday crowd on Facebook. It’s either that the last 15 years didn’t happen, or some simply accept that the way to chasing and prosecuting a group of terrorists is to invade two countries and kill millions.
The events in Paris are terrible and cannot be condoned, but they have not happened in a vacuum. We don’t seem to care as much when it’s a car bomb in the Middle East taking out 200, and that’s why I didn’t change my Facebook profile to a French flag today. I’d look like a hypocrite that only gave a toss when it was Western lives that have been taken, which is what we’ve collectively looked like, from Middle Eastern perspectives at least.
We won’t find a way out of this unless we’re prepared to acknowledge what we have done. The clash of civilisations narrative of the early 2000s became tragically self-fulfilling with the illegal wars the coalition of the willing undertook. The situation in France is terrifying. Marine Le Pen’s National Front party already have broad support, and this is against a backdrop of the political system always trying to fuck them up. You cannot help but draw comparisons with the Weimar Republic; a leadership perceived as ineffective (Hollande’s approval ratings are in the 20-25% range), a perceived enemy within threat, only swapping Muslims for Jews as antagonists and a right wing party ready to sort it all out.
Europe is unnecessarily at a crossroads. What was it they said about the price of freedom? Something to do with eternal vigilance. We have to address the short-term steps, but if we don’t take action on long-term resolution, the continent is going to become a police state. The Stade de France bombings alone could have massive implications for those that attend football, an area which some would argue is already overpoliced.
I realise that this has been a bit of a ramble by now. Not my attention to offend anyone at this very sensitive time; I genuinely want the best for everybody. I just think we might better achieve that by ditching the notion that we’re automatically the “best”. History is not going to judge the West of the early 21st century with much kindness. When it starts treating 21st century peeps with more respect is really down to us.